Both passing off and trademark infringement protect brand identity and prevent unfair competition, but they differ in scope, legal basis, and application. Understanding these differences is essential for businesses seeking to safeguard their intellectual property.
What is Trademark Infringement?
Trademark infringement occurs when someone uses a registered trademark without permission in a way that confuses or misleads consumers about the source of goods or services.
Key Features:
-
Only applies to registered trademarks.
-
Unauthorized use can include identical or confusingly similar marks.
-
Remedies include civil action (injunctions, damages, account of profits) and criminal penalties (imprisonment, fines) under the Trade Marks Act, 1999.
Example: Using a logo almost identical to Nike’s swoosh on sports shoes without permission constitutes trademark infringement.
What is Passing Off?
Passing off protects unregistered trademarks or brand identity under common law. It occurs when a business misrepresents its goods or services as those of another, causing harm to the original brand’s goodwill.
Key Features:
-
Applies to unregistered trademarks, trade names, get-ups, or branding elements.
-
Focuses on misrepresentation, goodwill, and consumer deception.
-
Legal action is taken under the common law principle of passing off.
-
Remedies include injunctions, damages, and accounts of profits.
Example: Selling chocolates under the brand name “Amool” to mislead consumers into believing they are purchasing Amul chocolates constitutes passing off.
Key Differences Between Passing Off and Trademark Infringement
| Aspect | Trademark Infringement | Passing Off |
|---|---|---|
| Legal Basis | Statutory law (Trademarks Act, 1999) | Common law principle |
| Requirement | Must be a registered trademark | Can be unregistered trademark or brand identity |
| Scope | Protects the exclusive rights of registered marks | Protects goodwill and reputation of a business |
| Proof Needed | Use of identical or confusingly similar mark | Misrepresentation, goodwill, and likelihood of deception |
| Remedies | Civil and criminal remedies (injunction, damages, imprisonment, fines) | Civil remedies (injunction, damages, account of profits) |
| Focus | Unauthorized use of registered mark | Misleading the public or misrepresenting source |
Conclusion
-
Trademark infringement is concerned with violating registered trademark rights, providing both civil and criminal remedies.
-
Passing off protects unregistered marks or brand reputation, ensuring that businesses are not misrepresented or their goodwill exploited.
-
Both mechanisms are critical for protecting intellectual property, maintaining consumer trust, and preventing unfair competition.